Skip to content
October 22, 2011 / keeponspinning

Prenatal Test for Depression

George, unanimously the favorite sibling

Depression hurts.  Physically and emotionally.  It is a major cause of family stress, social alienation, health problems and inability to function at work.   The National Institute of Mental health  says that the lifetime incidence of depression  – serious depression – among Americans is 16.5%.  It’s important to understand the different statistics here.  This means that if you take 1000 babies,  follow them along their whole lives, and keep track of things, at the end of their lives 165 of them will have suffered from true depression.   Beyond that, at any given moment, only about one third of Americans would consider themselves very happy. 

Eliza, who is happy and loved.

 Depression causes unquantifiable agony and has an economic impact in the billions of dollar range.  (yes, billions.   83.1 billion dollars in 2000, for example. Of the 2000 total, 26.1 billion dollars (31%) were direct medical costs, 5.4 billion dollars (7%) were suicide-related mortality costs, and 51.5 billion dollars (62%) were workplace costs).
 

Verity, at very low risk of ever being depressed.

 
 And it’s not just sadness.  People with depression have physical pain, too.  Depression is well documented to cause headaches, back pain, muscle pain, chest pain, digestive problems…   And depression has huge impacts on families.  I heard someone explain that living with a depressed person was like living with a black hole.  They just suck all the positive energy out of everything.
 

Lily, who is the most likely of her siblings to have a lifetime of happiness.

 I am absolutely, totally pro-life.  So I was very interested to read this week about a new DNA test that is going to be available to pregnant women in just a few months.  If this test, done with a sample of blood from a pregnant mother, is positive, there is a 99 % chance that her baby will be happy.  Remember than 16.5 % lifetime incidence of depression?  If this prenatal DNA test is positive, that rate falls to less than 7 %, probably much less, especially for boys. 
 

Nella, whose own happiness brings joy to so many other people.

 But the burdens this test places upon mothers is tremendous.  What if a mother gets a negative result?  Early in pregnancy, she knows that her child may not be spared the grief and difficulties of this suffering.  Depression causes suffering, it’s undeniable. 

Have you opened a new tab yet to google this new prenatal test for depression?  You will actually have to open two new pages and put two different studies together to learn how it works. 

First go here:  http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/ajmg.a.v155.10/issuetoc  (if you are a formal journal reading type of person) or if you prefer the blog version, you can go here:  http://www.brianskotko.com/index.php/blog

Both of those links are about happiness.  And more good stuff.  Totally amazingly good.  

And here is the link to the company, called Sequenom, who invented the new test:  http://www.sequenomcmm.com/home/patients/trisomy-21/

I can hear you way over here in my kitchen.  “Wait a minute!  That’s not a prenatal test for depression, that’s a Down Syndrome test!  I read about that!  They said it was great because now women don’t have to worry about risking a “normal” pregnancy by having an amniocentesis!”

Take a minute and think about it.  People with Down Syndrome are happier than the rest of us, and their families are thriving.  If you want footnotes about the rest of the mental health statistics, email me and I’ll send them along.  I am obviously very biased, as a passionately pro-life mama who has had two babies with Trisomy 21.  But I think if I had a positive prenatal test that could assure me that my baby would grow up liking himself, not an emotional burden to his siblings, at very low risk for depression… I’d be OK with that.  How about you?

About these ads

30 Comments

Leave a Comment
  1. Susanna / Oct 22 2011 3:14 am

    Elizabeth, brilliant!!! Bravo!!! *wild applause!*

    P.S. I only clap for things that are REAL and TRUE.

  2. patti rice (@APerfectLily) / Oct 22 2011 3:27 am

    crying here of course. LOVE LOVE LOVE this. Thank you for including my sweet Lily (and Tyler!) in this. My husband said you just inspired a sermon! oxox from Oregon

    • Nicole / Oct 23 2011 1:05 pm

      Another great post Elizabeth! Patti ~ so fun seeing Lily on here!

  3. Harriett / Oct 22 2011 4:48 am

    If I ever gained anything in owning my shop…it was getting to know you as a friend, teacher and “doctor on call”!

    Each and every child is a gift from God…thanks for giving the unborn a voice. What beautiful examples of “happy”!

  4. Danielle Barton / Oct 22 2011 6:13 am

    LOVE LOVE LOVE this post. Just found your blog from Patti Rice (I guess I’ll get to hear the sermon inspire by you because I go to their church. (: my sister is married to Patti’s oldest son). Wow. I seriously want to print out your post and read it to everyone. I LOVE it. Did I mention that i love it? I clicked “Comments” expecting to read hundreds and saw only 3 – but SERIOUSLY!?! This post needs to be printed in a magazine or something. You SOOO hit the nail on the head.

    So. Thank you (:

  5. esther paris / Oct 22 2011 12:59 pm

    I love you and all your babies are joys to behold. Yes, I too would be OK with a positive Trisomy-21 depression-avoidance prenatal diagnosis. I am all too familiar with depression and its consequences. Hugs!

  6. Cynthia / Oct 22 2011 1:01 pm

    This is a great post! Off to share…

  7. Ginny / Oct 22 2011 1:18 pm

    I’m applauding too!! Love your thoughts on this–perfect and true!!!

  8. cate / Oct 22 2011 2:33 pm

    I don’t think depression and the “happiness” attributed to people with DS are mutually exclusive. I understand your point, but it seems inaccurate to say that having DS guarantees that a person won’t suffer from depression too.

  9. Beth JM / Oct 22 2011 2:40 pm

    We have 8 children through birth and adoption. We have a multitude of special needs in our family including Down syndrome. I can say from personal experience that our Down syndrome child may have more medical needs but she is the easiest, most friendly and interactive child we have.She has the sweetest spirit of all my children. She brings joy to everyone who sees her and is happy most the time (unless she hears the dreaded word “no” when she wants to do something). How I wish mothers knew there is joy in having a Down syndrome child. OR, if they feel they can not parent a Down syndrome child, there is a great option ~ life and adoption!

  10. Laura / Oct 22 2011 2:48 pm

    fantastic post. I am the proud sister-in-law of the most wonderful brother-in-law ever (who happens to be a 37 year old with Downs). uncle keith is a joy and my children love their uncle tremendously. we are blessed to have a brother who truly enjoys life- and milkshakes, a dinner out, football, the Lord, and his family. he is patient with his four year old nephew who wants to play cars, build (and wreck) lego creations, and is the perfect gentleman with our grls. i will be passing this link on to my mother in law- enjoy your sweet George!

  11. mmfollbaum / Oct 22 2011 3:00 pm

    Just beautiful.

    Love and blessings,
    Michele F.

  12. Theresa / Oct 22 2011 5:02 pm

    Beautiful, just beautiful.

  13. Elizabeth K. / Oct 22 2011 8:49 pm

    Wonderful wonderful, SMART post. Thank you!

  14. Christina Schye / Oct 23 2011 1:19 am

    Hi, I found you through Patti, love this post, and many of the others I’ve read! I have a 2 year old with Ds, and am an oncology nurse. I watched George reading, and LOVE it! Can you tell me how you taught him? Did you do the “my baby can read”? Kellan is very good at signs, and has a few words-go, no, ball…I’ve heard of different programs and would love to try something, but they are all so expensive, I’d like to know what’s worked for others. My email is christina0469@msn.com. Thanks!
    Christina

  15. Kimberly / Oct 23 2011 2:12 am

    This brought tears to my eyes. Beautifully written.

  16. Teri C. / Oct 24 2011 12:40 pm

    This is beautiful, Elizabeth.

  17. Andrea Maciejewski / Oct 24 2011 4:49 pm

    I’m not much of a blog follower, but I am going to share and follow this one. BEAUTIFUL! God bless you!

  18. Jen / Oct 24 2011 6:20 pm

    Amazing!! Soooo well written!! I couldn’t agree more!

  19. Shannon / Oct 25 2011 12:24 am

    Found you through Patti and Lilys blog. And I am so glad I did. This was such a great perspective on everything. I can’t thank you enough for these words of incite. shared it with my friends

  20. RK / Oct 25 2011 4:39 am

    Great perspective and really good food for thought. I think I may link to you on this one!

  21. Dad / Oct 25 2011 12:31 pm

    Elizabeth,
    Nicely, beautifully, professionally, powerfully done.

    From your proud Father

  22. Kathy / Oct 25 2011 3:01 pm

    Thank you and bless you for this post. Yes, our children have a rare gift of natural joy… my daughter’s bus driver recently told me, “It’s impossible to be in a bad mood around her!” What a poor world it would be without them.

  23. kimberlee / Oct 25 2011 5:20 pm

    Fabulous, Elizabeth!

  24. Katherine Lauer / Oct 27 2011 1:35 am

    You are a gas and I love you, Elizabeth! This is wonderful. Touche! You go, girl!

  25. Melissa / Nov 1 2011 6:38 pm

    Found you through Patti too. Love this post!

  26. Tamie / Nov 4 2011 3:17 am

    BEAUTIFUL post.

Trackbacks

  1. Weekend Reading « Yellow Pencil Stub
  2. Two weeks and three days: Q & A | The Blessing of Verity

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 183 other followers

%d bloggers like this: